06 May 2010

IN MEMORIAM: Italian mezzo-soprano Giulietta Simionato, 1910 - 2010

Italian mezzo-soprano Giulietta Simionato (1910 - 2010) as Santuzza in Mascagni's CAVALLERIA RUSTICANA

GIULIETTA SIMIONATO

12 May 1910 – 5 May 2010

The life and work of the remarkable Italian mezzo-soprano Giulietta Simionato, who passed away in Rome a week before she would have marked her 100th birthday, are too familiar to require detailed recounting.  She was, especially during the last two decades of her nearly-forty-year career, the reigning Italian dramatic mezzo-soprano in all of the world’s principal opera houses, her performances as Azucena (in which role she débuted at the Metropolitan Opera, opposite Carlo Bergonzi, Antonietta Stella, and Leonard Warren) and Amneris remaining unsurpassed standards more than forty-four years after her retirement in 1966.  She was also a pioneer in singing Rossini’s Rosina in the original mezzo-soprano keys in an age in which the role had been appropriated by coloratura sopranos and in singing La Cenerentola, which aside from the famous Glyndebourne production with Spanish mezzo-soprano Marina de Gabarain was ignored until another Spaniard, Teresa Berganza, espoused the opera in the 1970’s.

From a purely personal perspective, Giulietta Simionato was an exceptional artist, which is to say that she was an artist of exceptions.  In my view, the role of Santuzza in Pietro Mascagni’s Cavalleria rusticana requires a dramatic soprano – except for Giulietta Simionato, whose voice was of such richness and expansive security in the upper register that it could easily encompass the merely technical aspects of the role while tearing into the dramatic flesh of the opera with special intensity.  Good as the work of many international singers has been in the role, Bizet’s Carmen possesses a quintessentially French insouciance that is best enacted by French singers – except for Giulietta Simionato, whose Carmen seduces with sultry arrogance and an alluring integrity even when sung in Italian.  Valentine in Giacomo Meyerbeer’s Les Huguenots, first sung by the much-discussed French soprano Cornélie Falcon, demands a powerful singer of the elusive Fach named for its creator – except for Giulietta Simionato, whose performances (albeit sung in Italian) of the role in the famous 1962 La Scala production with Dame Joan Sutherland and Franco Corelli, audibly from the timbre of the voice the work of a mezzo-soprano, shone like meteors even in a very starry firmament.  [Maria Callas, who was perhaps closer than any other singer active in 1962 to being a true Falcon, entered into negotiations with La Scala to sing Valentine in the Huguenots production, but nothing came of it.  Could even La Divina have sung the role more magnificently than Simionato?]

It was opposite Maria Callas, at La Scala in 1957, that Giulietta Simionato enjoyed one of her greatest triumphs, as Giovanna Seymour to Callas’ Anna Bolena.  In interviews conducted after her retirement, she often cited her performances as Giovanna Seymour in 1957 as the pinnacle of her career, and hearing any of the available recordings of the 14 April performance reveals at once the work of an incomparable singer at her breathtaking best.  The La Scala production of Anna Bolena was also a milestone in Callas’ career, and hearing the two singers dueling with their voices in the great duet for Anna and Giovanna – the incredible anger and betrayal of Callas’ Anna as she accuses Simionato’s Giovanna of being the rival for whom Enrico has spurned and condemned her and the horrified guilt and sorrow of Simionato’s Giovanna, a woman who knows that she is soon to be Queen, still riveting after so many years – is to hear the interaction between two artists for whom the music was a genuine conversation, not between a Queen and her would-be usurper but between two women, both of them ambitious but desperately frightened, who loved the same man.  It is not the art that conceals art or, as Leoncavallo put it, art that is a slice of life: it simply is life that, for those moments in the hands of great artists, happens to take place in song.

There is no more charming recording of Giulietta Simionato than her account with baritone Ettore Bastianini of ‘Anything You Can Do’ from Irving Berlin’s Annie Get Your Gun, part of the gala sequence in Herbert von Karajan’s DECCA recording of Johann Strauss’ Die Fledermaus.  Making her entrance with a sepulchral ‘Reverenza’ (a reference to her success as Mistress Quickly in Verdi’s Falstaff), this is a singer who is not afraid to poke fun at herself.  Her interactions with Bastianini in exaggeratedly-accented English are delicious: the jewel is surely when she responds to Bastianini’s assertion that he ‘can live on bread and cheese’ with the deadpan line, complete with absurdly-trilled r, ‘so can a rrrrrrat!’  It is cute, it is genuinely hilarious – above all, it is the essence of Giulietta Simionato.

As a modest collector of operatic memorabilia, principally photographs of singers whose work I admire, one of my most cherished possessions is a rare photograph (reproduced below), taken on the stage of La Scala in 1963, showing Giulietta Simionato as Santuzza on her knees at the feet of Franco Corelli as Turiddu, their expressions so passionate and yet so natural.  This description might apply with equal validity to Simionato’s artistry: as passionate as the fiery core of the earth and as natural as breathing.

BRAVA, Giulietta, grazie, e addio.

Giulietta Simionato and Franco Corelli in CAVALLERIA RUSTICANA at La Scala, 1963

CD REVIEW: André-Ernest-Modeste Grétry – ANDROMAQUE (K. Deshayes, M.R. Wesseling, S. Guèze, T. Christoyannis; Glossa GCD 921620)

Grétry: ANDROMAQUE (Deshayes, Wesseling, Guèze, Christoyannis; Glossa GCD 921620)

ANDRÉ-ERNEST-MODESTE GRÉTRY (1741 – 1813): Andromaque – K. Deshayes (Andromaque), M.R. Wesseling (Hermione), S. Guèze (Pyrrhus), T. Christoyannis (Oreste), M. Heim (Phœnix), É. Hache (une Greque), E. Hurtrait (un Greq); Les Chantres du Centre de Musique Baroque de Versailles, Chœur du Concert Spirituel; Orchestre du Concert Spirituel; Hervé Niquet [recorded at Salle Henry Le Bœuf, Palais des Beaux-Arts, Brussels, in October 2009, in conjunction with concert performances in Brussels and Paris; Glossa GCD 921620]

To all but those who are specialists in French opera of the late Eighteenth Century, the Belgian-born composer André-Ernest-Modeste Grétry is most remembered for a score that he did not compose: the opera Pikovaya Dama (or The Queen of Spades), in which Tchaikovsky quoted the aria ‘Je crains de lui parler la nuit’ from Grétry’s Richard Coeur-de-lion as the Old Countess recalls her fast-and-loose youth in Paris.  Richard Coeur-de-lion was widely considered the masterpiece of its composer, who was a seminal figure in post-Rameau French music and some of whose fifty or so operas held French stages until the end of the Nineteenth Century (a record that the operas of Puccini are only just achieving, by comparison).  With Tchaikovsky’s appropriation of ‘Je crains de lui parler la nuit’ and the adoption of another aria from Richard Coeur-de-lion, ‘O Richard, o mon roi,’ by Royalists during the French Revolution, Grétry’s influence seems merely topical from an historical perspective, but his music was almost universally admired during the late Eighteenth Century, particularly the operas Zémire et Azor (recorded for French EMI/Pathé by the wonderful Mady Mesplé) and La caravane du Caire (which is similar in theme and certain efforts at ‘local color’ in scoring to Die Entführung aus dem Serail, though Mozart’s opera was not heard in France until fifteen years after the premiere of La caravane du Caire), and exerted a considerable influence over the composers active in France during the 1790’s and first two decades of the Nineteenth Century, especially Luigi Cherubini and Étienne Méhul.

The young Grétry honed his craft – as did many young composers in the Eighteenth Century – by studying in Italy, having been inspired by hearing the operas of Baldassaro Galuppi and Giovanni Battista Pergolesi in his native Liège.  During his five years in Italy, Grétry studied with Giovanni Battista Casali, maestro di coro at the Basilica of St. John Lateran, one of the last composers of unaccompanied polyphonic choral music in the tradition of Palestrina.  Learning more by absorption than by academic prowess, Grétry returned to France with understanding of the prevalent Italian operatic forms of the time.  Having devoted himself upon his return to the French opéra comique, still in its formative stages, with his best works like Zémire et Azor (which is based on the ‘beauty and the beast’ legend) and L’amant jaloux (the music and text of which are thought to have influenced Mozart and Lorenzo da Ponte in their work on Le Nozze di Figaro), Grétry produced recognizably French works that built upon the examples of Rameau but also introduced Italianate elements such as complex coloratura.

Taking up the tradition of French tragédie lyrique inherited from Lully and Rameau, no composer was more influential in France during the latter half of the Eighteenth Century than Christoph Willibald von Gluck, whose ‘reform’ operas of the 1760’s and 1770’s sought to purge the music of the French lyric theatre of Italianate excesses and return to a style of utterance that aspired to the dramatic purity of Classical Greek theatre.  The extent to which Grétry was directly influenced by Gluck’s work is impossible to ascertain, but the controversial success of the premiere of Gluck’s Armide, in which his ideals of reform were fully explored, in 1777 may well have played a decisive role in Grétry’s decision to accept the commission to compose his first tragédie lyrique, sadly the only one of his several efforts in the genre which seems to have performed.  Grétry’s Andromaque was conceived as an ambitious setting of the famous literary tragedy by Jean Racine, and legal wrangling with the Comédie Française, by which institution the performance rights to Racine’s play were held, delayed the first performance of Grétry’s opera – which had entered rehearsals as early as 1778 – until 6 June 1780.  The opera did not manage to win either the unfettered appreciation of audiences or the praise of critics, by whom it was particularly condemned for its profusion of choruses, which led to the charge that the score was more an oratorio than an opera.  Grétry and his librettist, Louis-Guillaume Pitra, made significant alterations to the opera, most notably replacing Racine’s tragic ending (which is retained in the present recording) with a happier finale, in advance of a revival of the opera in 1781.  After this second run of performances, which won the favor of audiences, Andromaque seems not to have been performed again until the concert performances in October 2009 upon which this recording is based.

Listeners who are familiar with Grétry’s opéras comiques will encounter an entirely different sound world in Andromaque, one with similarities to the music that Gluck was contemporaneously composing for Paris but even stronger ties to Rameau’s mid-century operas.  The style of vocal declamation is similar to that heard in Gluck’s two operas on the myth of Iphigénie, with fast-paced recitative developing into brief but emotive arioso.  In an opera that runs for slightly less than ninety minutes (as recorded) even with the customary ballet, there is no room for long-winded arias and ensembles.  Though never reaching the level of inspiration achieved by Gluck in his finest operas for Paris, Grétry proves in Andromaque that he possessed a sensitive understanding of the tragédie lyrique tradition, composing music that is apt for the dramatic situations and unfailingly attractive if not ultimately memorable.  The Ouverture is perhaps the weakest number in the score, but the opera’s three acts move at a swift pace and contain much music that, while not distinctive, is never less than enjoyable.

The recording by Le Concert Spirituel and Hervé Niquet, renowned for their enterprising performances and recordings of French Baroque repertory, gives an impressive introduction to Grétry’s score.  Maestro Niquet and his instrumental ensemble are as comfortable in Andromaque as in the music of Charpentier, Lully, or Marais, shaping the music with articulation born of their experience with Baroque music but attentiveness to the stylistic nuances of Grétry’s music, which in this case is curiously suggestion of his forbears, his contemporaries, and his musical successors all at once: it is possible to hear the cornerstones laid by Rameau as well as the framework built by Gluck, but there is also the feeling that Les Troyens is not too far distant on the horizon.  This is perhaps to give Grétry’s musical inventiveness greater credit than it truly deserves, but Andromaque is a score in which there are subtle stirrings of Romanticism, perhaps more by chance than by intention.  Maestro Niquet’s leadership is alert to this sense of the opera being of both past and future, and the singers and musicians of Le Concert Spirituel – the former increased by the participation of Les Chantres du Centre de Musique Baroque de Versailles – sound devoted to their tasks and to Grétry’s music throughout.

The quartet of principal soloists assembled for the concerts and recording is excellent and, ideally for Grétry, comprised of singers with experience in both Baroque and later repertories.  Dramatically, the pick of the lot is Greek baritone Tassis Christoyannis, a singer whose fiery reGreek baritone Tassis Christoyanniscorded performances (especially of Bajazet in Tamerlano) in mdg’s series of Händel operas have been thrillingly virile displays of technically-assured singing.  Given leaner material with which to work as Orestes in Andromaque, Mr. Christoyannis scales back the power of his singing, unleashing the full frisson of his voice only when required by the dramatic situation.  Having succumbed to the demands of Hermione, whom he loves, Orestes is complicit in the slaying of Pyrrhus.  By the time that Pyrrhus has fallen to Greek swords, however, Hermione realizes that she was not in full command of her reason when she directed Orestes to kill Pyrrhus, and Orestes brings the opera to a close with his own crushing grief and madness.  The brutality of this dénouement is conveyed with complete sincerity by Mr. Christoyannis, whose vocal quality fully equals the dramatic swagger of his singing.

The catalyst of the tragic actions that lead to Orestes’ madness is Hermione (the daughter of Menelaus and Helen of Troy), sung with characteristic intensity by Swiss mezzo-soprano Maria Riccarda Wesseling, who is also a veteran of many fine productions and recordings of Händel operas.  There is a darkness aroSwiss mezzo-soprano Maria Riccarda Wesseling [Photo by Emilio Brizzi]und the edges of Ms. Wesseling’s tone that allows her to suggest pathos without causing her vocal lines to droop.  Whereas she has sometimes  struggled to maintain steadiness as Händel heroes, the music that Grétry composed for Hermione gives her the opportunity to fully express her femininity.  Hermione’s music is not of the difficulty of what she frequently sings in Händel roles, and perhaps this relative simplicity focuses the impact of Ms. Wesseling’s voice, uniting the purity of her technique with the emotional directness of her manner of singing.  In truth, Hermione’s music does not plumb the depths of passion suggested by her text, but the integrity of Ms. Wesseling’s performance closes the psychological gaps in Grétry’s music with heartfelt, beautiful singing.

Grétry gave some of the best music in Andromaque to Pyrrhus, the victim of Hermione’s jealousy and Orestes’ misplaced vengeance.  The role receives a very fine performance in this recording by young French tenor Sébastien Guèze, a tremendously promising singer who alternated with Roberto Alagna in the 2007 premiere production by Opéra Municipal de Marseilles of Vladimir Cosma’s Marius et Fanny and won the appreciation of Gounod fanciers throughout the world with a beautifully-sung Roméo in a Concertgebouw performance of Roméo et Juliette broadcast over Netherlands Radio.  The youthful pliancy of Mr. GuèzFrench tenor Sébastien Guèze [Photo by Lucile Leber]e’s tenor is very appealing, and he enters into his part in Grétry’s tragedy with touching conviction.  Throughout his performance, Mr. Guèze’s tone is refreshingly even, without the ugly or barely-concealed breaks at the passaggio that mar the singing of many young singers.  Mr. Guèze’s voice is a bright but rich lyric tenor, with sweetness and freedom in the upper register that are reminiscent of some of the most refined French tenors of past generations, not least the sublime Michel Sénéchal.  Mr. Guèze’s voice is of proportions larger than Sénéchal’s, allowing him to comfortably sing roles like Rodolfo in La Bohème, but he shares his artistic ancestor’s affinities for pointed delivery of text and musical expression that touch the heart even when the music he sings is not of the highest quality.  With this performance, Mr. Guèze manages not only to convince the listener that Grétry was a composer who, in his music for Pyrrhus, aspired to the heights reached by Rameau and Gluck but also that his own voice is among the finest tenors of his generation.

The title role is entrusted to French soprano Karine Deshayes, who at relatively short notice replaced Dutch soprano Judith van Wanroij in both the concerts and recording sessions.  Like her colleagues in this performance, she sings a varied repertory: celebrated in Europe for her work in Baroque music, she made her début at the Metropolitan  Opera in 2006 as Siebel in Gounod’s Faust.  As AndroFrench soprano Karine Deshayes [Photo by Vincent Jacques]maque, Ms. Deshayes brings a youthfully vibrant voice that hovers, like those of some of the great exponents of tragédie lyrique of bygone years (Dame Janet Baker and Lorraine Hunt Lieberson, for instance), between mezzo-soprano and soprano tessituras.  The absolute security of her voice is upset by none of the demands placed on it by Grétry’s music, and if there is not the last measure of grandeur that one expects from a figure such as Andromache – the grieving widow of Trojan hero Hector (who, in a tangential nod to Rameau, was descended from Dardanus) whose perseverance in her grief and determination to safeguard her son precipitate the tragic actions of Racine’s play and Grétry’s opera – that is to be credited to the composer rather than the singer.  Ms. Deshayes’ performance is touching and sung with complete confidence, making the most of the music that Grétry gave her: one can ask for nothing more.

It must be conceded that Grétry’s Andromaque is not the forgotten masterpiece that some of the other scores resurrected by Hervé Niquet and Le Concert Spirituel have proved to be, not least the marvelous Sémélé of Marin Marais.  As always, though, the artists involved with this recording have given of their best, and Glossa’s engineers have provided typically first-rate sound to complement the artists’ performances.  It is interesting to hear Grétry’s efforts at tragédie lyrique, which was as much a part of his musical heritage as the opéras comiques for which he is remembered, and of course a vital and sometimes thrilling element of the Period Practice movement is encountering carefully-prepared, expertly-executed performances of imperfect works.  Andromaque is an imperfect work in that its style did not draw from Grétry the brilliance and wit that flow so charmingly through his opéras comiques, and if the music of Andromaque displays no startling individuality it also avoids parody and facile imitation.  Andromaque is clearly the product of an important composer who merely was not working within his element.  The opera receives from Maestro Niquet, Le Concert Spirituel, and a team of excellent singers a performance that maximizes its eloquence and minimizes its deficiencies – in short, the best possible introduction for Twenty-First-Century listeners.

04 May 2010

CD REVIEW: Gioachino Rossini – L’ITALIANA IN ALGERI (M. Pizzolato, L. Brownlee, L. Regazzo, B. De Simone; NAXOS 8.660284-85)

Rossini - L'ITALIANA IN ALGERI (Pizzolato, Brownlee, Regazzo - NAXOS 8.660284-85)

GIOACHINO ROSSINI (1792 – 1868): L’Italiana in Algeri – M. Pizzolato (Isabella), L. Brownlee (Lindoro), L. Regazzo (Mustafà), B. De Simone (Taddeo), R. Gonzalez (Elvira), E. Giannoulidou (Zulma), G. Mastrototaro (Haly); Transylvania State Philharmonic Choir, Cluj; Virtuosi Brunensis; Alberto Zedda [recorded ‘live’ at the Kursaal, Bad Wildbad, Germany, during the XXth Rossini in Wildbad Festival; 2, 3, & 5 July 2008; NAXOS 8.660284-85]

Though it premiered at Venice’s Teatro San Benedetto on 22 May 1813, when its composer was less than three months past his twenty-first birthday, L’Italiana in Algeri was Gioachino Rossini’s eleventh opera, following closely on the heels of the acclaimed premiere (also in Venice, at the famous Teatro La Fenice) of Tancredi.  The role of the barnstorming Isabella was first sung by Italian contralto Marietta Marcolini, who with her participation in the L’Italiana premiere created the fourth of five roles that the young Rossini composed for her.  Also present in the first-night cast of L’Italiana was the celebrated bass Filippo Galli, a talented and versatile singer for whom Rossini composed several of his most demanding basso roles and who also created the role of Enrico (Henry VIII) in Donizetti’s Anna Bolena in 1830.

Musically, L’Italiana in Algeri is enlivened by the clever way in which its young composer employed traditional aspects of Classically-inspired opera seria, a then-rapidly-declining genre with a pedigree extending back to the Italian operas of Händel, within the confines of the dramma giocoso (a categorization that it shares with Mozart’s Don Giovanni) he was creating to the libretto of Angelo Anelli.  The frenetic pace and famous crescendo of Rossini’s maturity are already present in L’Italiana in Algeri, but the score benefits from a melodic preciosity that is remarkable even among Rossini’s operas.  The two cavatinas for Lindoro, ‘Languir per una bella’ in the First Act and ‘Oh come il cor di giubilo’ in the Second, possess beautiful melodic lines that are as reminiscent of Mozart as of Italian bel canto.  Here, however, a measure of uncertainty creeps in: it is well known that the secco recitatives and Haly’s famous aria ‘Le femmine d’Italia’ were not composed by Rossini but by an anonymous collaborator (whether the collaboration was necessitated by the speed of the opera’s creation, which required less than a month at most, by details of the first production that are lost to history, or by other circumstances remains a matter for debate), perhaps the Italian composer Luigi Mosca, an older contemporary of Rossini whose own setting of Anelli’s libretto for L’Italiana in Algeri was first performed in Milan in 1808.  Bolstered by the fact that Rossini composed the virtuosic aria ‘Concedi, amor pietoso’ to replace 'Oh come il cor di giubilo’ for a later production of L’Italiana in which the original Lindoro, Serafino Gentili, reprised his part, modern scholarship suggests that the lovely original aria may also have been composed by someone other than Rossini.  [Despite its dubious authorship, ‘Oh come il cor di giubilo’ is preferred in the present performance.  Performances of ‘Concedi, amor pietoso’ are available as an appendix to Jesús López-Cobos’ recording of L’Italiana in Algeri, on which it is sung by tenor Raúl Giménez, and on recital discs, notably the DECCA collection of Rossini Arias sung by Juan Diego Flórez.]  There is not in ‘Oh come il cor di giubilo’ the obvious falling-off in quality apparent in the numbers composed for La Cenerentola by Luca Agolini, so its composer – whether Rossini, Mosca, or a forgotten third party – took pains to match the aria in both style and musical integrity with the rest of the score.  A testimony to the genius of the young composer, L’Italiana in Algeri is the rare early bel canto comic opera that is both filled from beginning (in this case, a rollicking Overture that remains a concert favorite) to end with first-rate music and, in a good performance, can prove genuinely funny.

Fortunately for listeners, a good performance is precisely what the opera receives in this recording, derived from three performances at the Twentieth Rossini in Wildbad Festival in Germany during July 2008.  Orchestral playing by the Virtuosi Brunensis, the ensemble with which NAXOS recorded their splendid account of Rossini’s Tancredi with Ewa Podleś and Sumi Jo, is excellent, benefiting from the fine-tuning of period-instrument practice but very much adapting their approach to Rossini’s idiom.  The singing from the members of the Transylvania State Philharmonic Choir – variously portraying eunuchs, pirates, and slaves – is similarly impressive, precise but also conveying a grand sense of fun (and, when appropriate, of dread and mock heroics).  Presiding over the performance is Italian maestro Alberto Zedda, a tireless advocate of the music of Rossini as its composer intended it to be performed who celebrated his eightieth birthday six months to the day before the first performance that contributed to this recording.  Like the performances of Karl Böhm, Otto Klemperer, and Tullio Serafin at similar ages, Maestro Zedda’s spirited leadership of this recording of L’Italiana in Algeri suggests the work of a man trying to prove his vitality.  After a career that has yielded many worthy performances of Rossini operas (including the aforementioned NAXOS Tancredi), no proof of Maestro Zedda’s mastery of the repertory is required, but this recording proves anew that few conductors active today share the same idiomatic grasp of Rossini’s music that Maestro Zedda has at his command.  Maestro Zedda knows instinctively when his influence is required to keep things moving and when the music flows without manipulation.  The singers are given support consistently sensitive to their own needs and the requirements of the music.  As in most of Maestro Zedda’s performances, interpolated top notes at the ends of numbers are mostly eschewed in favor of presumably more authentic flourishes on high within the internal ornamentation of arias and ensembles.  Maestro Zedda understands how Rossini worked as a composer, and his leadership ensures that this performance of L’Italiana in Algeri ‘works’ both musically and theatrically.

Unlike many productions of bel canto operas, this Rossini in Wildbad production enjoyed the work of uniformly good singers in secondary roles.  As Elvira, wife of the philandering Mustafà, Tenerife-born soprano Ruth Gonzalez sings with secure tone and pointed diction, managing to convey exasperation without seeming an annoying shrew.  Zulma, Elvira’s slave and confidante, receives a performance of charm from Greek mezzo-soprano Elsa Giannoulidou, her contributions to ensembles inspiring the wish that Rossini – or, considering the troublesome provenance of L’Italiana in Algeri, someone – had graced her role with an aria.  Italian bass Giulio Mastrototaro ideally captures the spirit of Haly’s (but not Rossini’s) aria in praise of the wily women of Italy, ‘Le femmine d’Italia,’ and elsewhere adds delightfully to ensembles.

Italian bass Bruno De Simone has made a specialty of basso buffo roles in bel canto operas and has sung Taddeo in L’Italiana in Algeri throughout Europe, including at the prestigious festival devoted to the operas of Rossini in his hometown of Pesaro.  This experience is evident in Mr. De Simone’s wonderful comic timing, exercised to maximum effect in ensembles and in a well-sung account of Taddeo’s aria, ‘Ho un gran peso sulla testa.’  If Mr. De Simone’s tone is no longer rock-solid, his performance never falters.

Mustafà is one of those roles that if played for laughs can seem unbearably insipid and if played as an humorless tyrant quickly becomes insufferable.  It is the sort of part that, like Verdi’s (or Salieri’s, Balfe’s, or Nicolai’s) Falstaff, requires both comedy and dignity in order to prove wholly effective.  Italian bass Lorenzo Regazzo is faItalian bass Lorenzo Regazzomiliar with the traditional roles of basses as tyrants and villains in Italian opera from his considerable work in Baroque music.  Mr. Regazzo’s Mustafà is a relatively straightforward performance with none of the foolishness that mars many performances of the role.  On balance, Mr. Regazzo’s Mustafà may be too straight-laced for those listeners who prefer Rossini’s buffo roles enacted on a broader scale, but there can be few complaints about Mr. Regazzo’s singing.  Mr. Regazzo is admittedly stronger in the role’s bravura passages than in roaring and bawling, but his tone is secure throughout the range.  He knows his way round the role, and his command of Rossini’s tricky coloratura is several notches above what most of his rivals achieve (the incomparable Samuel Ramey excepted).  This Mustafà’s beylik may be somewhat tame, but it is on sound musical footing.

With two fine arias and engaging contributions to ensembles to his credit, the role of Lindoro is a gift to a leggiero tenor with the bravura technique required for Rossini.  Most modern exponents of Rossini’s tenor roles are essentially lyric tenors who, through careful study, have cultivated coloratura ability: the true tenore di grazia, noted as much for a firm grasp of the lowest notes of the tenor range as for comfort in the vocal stratosphere, is virtually a musical unicorn in the sense that there are people who believe that they have encountered them but closer inspection reveals that what they actually witnessed were rather more ordinary equines with some extraordinary qualities.  Even in a field prominently populated by a world-renowned singer, American tenor Lawrence Brownlee is anything but ordinary.  With an ever-increasing repertory of Rossini roles in his vocal arsenal (including Rinaldo in the Metropolitan Opera’s premiere production of Armida by Mary Zimmerman), Mr. Brownlee has emerged during the past American tenor Lawrence Brownlee [Photo by Marty Umans]five years as one of the finest  Rossini tenors of his generation – and, as his performance as Lindoro in this recording attests, rightfully so.  Mr. Brownlee’s voice is warm but bright and seemingly produced with liquid ease that defies the difficulty of the music he sings.  In Lindoro’s music, Mr. Brownlee’s voice fizzes with idiomatic authority in coloratura passages, reaching formidable heights of virtuosity that never detract from the natural attractiveness of his tone.  Dramatically, Mr. Brownlee’s Lindoro is filled with touching longing for freedom and love but avoids sentimentality: he wears his heart on his sleeve, to be sure, but he is content in his big moments to thrust his hands into his pockets and let his music do the emotional heavy lifting.  This sort of thoughtful restraint is always welcome in Rossini’s comic operas, but it is Mr. Brownlee’s vocalism that demands one’s attention and ultimately wins one’s affection.  Both of Lindoro’s arias receive exceptionally poised, fleet-footed performances (though it is a pity that a very well-recorded cough mars the beginning of ‘Languir per una bella’), setting a new standard in the music.  This is exceptionally fine Rossini singing that rivals even the best singing of Mr. Brownlee’s competitors in bel canto repertory.

Musically and dramatically, the climax of L’Italiana in Algeri is the heroine Isabella’s second-act rondo, ‘Pensa alla patria,’ an exhortation to Mustafà’s Italian slaves to think of their fatherland and trust in Isabella’s commitment to deliver them from their servitude.  This description might give the impression of an ostentatiously grand utterance, something more appropriate to Fidelio than to a Rossini dramma giocoso.  Isabella’s rondo is an instance of Rossini’s use of an overtly opera seria style, but the wit of Rossini’s deployment of coloratura reveals the aria to be a worthy sister to Rosina’s ‘Una voce poco fa’ in Il Barbiere di Siviglia and Angelina’s ‘Non più mesta’ in La Cenerentola.  When one first hears Mr. Brownlee’s Lindoro, a nagging doubt that any performance could likewise offer an IsItalian mezzo-soprano Marianna Pizzolatoabella to match him arises.  From her first note, Italian mezzo-soprano Marianna Pizzolato – also a superb Malcolm in NAXOS’ live-from-Wildbad recording of La Donna del Lago (indeed, the finest aspect of that recording) – erases that doubt with a performance that meets the standard of Mr. Brownlee’s Lindoro note for thrilling note.  Like Mr. Regazzo, Ms. Pizzolato has extensive experience in Baroque music, but she also participated in masterclasses given by Anita Cerquetti and Magda Olivero, from whom she surely learned much about adapting one’s singing to the varying styles of different repertories.  Ms. Pizzolato has proved very fine indeed in Cavalli and Händel on disc, but she proves anew in this performance that Rossini’s idiom poses no challenges that are too much for her.  Her voice is dark-hued but ideally mobile, dealing expertly with the fearsome coloratura of her arias.  She is careful to articulate every note in her roulades, an effort that contributes to her nuanced reading of the text without seeming pedantic.  Her singing of the great rondo is commanding, the culmination of a performance that is, quite simply, Rossini singing of the highest quality.  When will the world’s most important opera companies realize, as NAXOS did from their inception, that the very famous singers are in many cases not the very best?

Aside from the cough that accompanies the opening strains of Lindoro’s ‘Languir per una bella,’ a few of its cousins from the throats of audience members and perhaps musicians, and occasional bumps, the sound engineered by NAXOS is excellent, even in passages of secco recitative.  It is also in secco recitatives that the balance seems most noticeably artificial, however: the continuo harpsichord, played very capably by Gianni Fabbrini, comes at the listener from an acoustical perspective identical to that in which the singers are framed, as if the singers were positioned around the harpsichord for a recital.  Balances are otherwise carefully-engineered to keep all of the singers front and center, with the orchestra and chorus given equal but never undue prominence, the final product suggesting a concert more than a staged performance with the typical changing perspectives imposed by theatrical blocking.  Editing has also been expertly done, which is to say that one is not aware that it has been done at all.  Despite occasional too-close perspectives, there is enough space around the voices to suggest their natural resonance.  All things considered, it is an admirably-rendered recording of live performances, another example that the lower prices of NAXOS recordings do not indicate lower production values.

L’Italiana in Algeri has not been recorded as frequently as some of Rossini’s other operas, especially Il Barbiere di Siviglia, but has been more fortunate than most of them in accumulating a small discography of recordings that are all competitive.  It is difficult to chose among Simionato with Valletti, Berganza with Alva, Valentini Terrani with either Benelli or Araiza, Horne with Palacio, Baltsa with Lopardo, and Larmore with Giménez.  NAXOS’ recording enters a field that is not crowded but is unusually distinguished, and it is wonderful (because it is so atypical) that – thanks to the singing of Marianna Pizzolato and Lawrence Brownlee – a recording made in the Twenty-First Century can more than hold its own.

30 April 2010

CD REVIEW: Edvard Grieg – VISITING GRIEG: Songs, Opp. 5, 12, 18, 26, 48 (Johannes Weisser, baritone; Søren Rastogi, piano)

VISITING GRIEG - Songs by Edvard Grieg: Johannes Weisser, baritone; Søren Rastogi, piano [Simax PSC1310]

EDVARD GRIEG (1843 – 1907): Selected Lieder from Opp. 5, 12, 18, 26, & 48 – Johannes Weisser, baritone; Søren Rastogi, piano [recorded in Oslo, Norway; Simax PSC1310]

Aside from the familiar ‘Jeg elsker Dig!’ (‘Ich liebe dich’ or ‘I love thee’), included in recitals and recordings by virtually every classically-trained singer at some point in his or her career, the Lieder of Edvard Grieg are far too little-known, even among the most dedicated advocates of Art Songs. There have been more in-depth recorded explorations of Grieg’s Lieder by Scandinavian and international artists, most notably by the towering Norwegian Wagnerian Kirsten Flagstad (whose beautiful recital of Scandinavian songs, recently restored to the catalogue by the Australian Eloquence branch of DECCA, introduced Grieg’s soulful Opus 67 cycle ‘Haugtussa’ to listeners outside of Scandinavia) and the Swedish mezzo-soprano Anne Sofie von Otter (whose disc of Grieg Songs with pianist Bengt Forsberg for Deutsche Grammophon remains after nearly twenty years a landmark both in Ms. von Otter’s discography and in the global appreciation of Grieg’s music), but this cache of musical treasures remains virtually unearthed when compared with the frequently-sung Lieder of Schubert, Schumann, Brahms, and Hugo Wolf. More so than most of his fellow composers, many of whose finest songs were settings of texts by dead writers, Grieg enjoyed incomparable opportunities of collaborating with his near-contemporaries Hans Christian Andersen, Henrik Ibsen, and Aasmund Olavsson Vinje, three of Scandinavia’s most influential writers of the Nineteenth Century. Though Grieg also set texts by the ‘usual suspects’ such as Goethe and Heine, his settings of texts by Scandinavian poets produced a body of work that, despite its lack of fame, elevated the Nordic song repertory to the standard set by Teutonic masters and that, as an embodiment of nationalistic pride, deservedly stands alongside German Lieder and French chansons.

Perhaps the relative obscurity of Grieg’s Songs can be attributed in part to the fact that among audiences and singers there are far fewer speakers of Norwegian than of French or German. There may exist a belief among singers and those who hear them that Scandinavian pieces are best left to native speakers, not unlike the operas and songs of Russian composers. This is surely true of the vocal works of Scandinavian composers such as Aarre Merikanto and Tauno Pylkkänen, but Grieg’s instrumental music retains a prominent place within the international concert repertory, especially in Europe. Music with Nordic accents is more easily assimilated than texts in Scandinavian languages, it seems, and perhaps it is true, then, that fears of incomprehension due to linguistic remoteness inhibit widespread dissemination of Grieg’s Songs. Musically, close examination reveals that many of Grieg’s finest Songs are of quality at least equal to that of the French and German ‘chestnuts’ of traditional Lieder repertories. Even taking into account linguistic trepidation, it seems unfathomable that the Lieder of a composer as widely-acclaimed as Grieg could remain, slightly more than a century after his death, an underexplored musical wilderness.

Those who love the music of Grieg, as well as those for whom Lieder are the most rewardingly intimate expressions of composers’ vocal artistries, are certain to have longed for pioneering young artists to follow in the tradition of Flagstad and von Otter, and this recital of twenty-four of Grieg’s most beautiful Songs (including the famous ‘Jeg elsker Dig!’) by Norwegian baritone Johannes Weisser and Danish pianist Søren Rastogi is an exceptional addition to the comparatively meager discography of Grieg’s Songs. One of Denmark’s most promising young musicians, Mr. Rastogi has pursued in addition to his considerable engagements as a soloist and chamber player a close collaboration with Mr. Weisser, and the dedication of this professional relationship pays impressive dividends in this recording. As an accompanist, Mr. Rastogi possesses that rare but vital trait: the ability to breathe, musically speaking, in tandem with a singer. Many sublimely gifted concert pianists are poor accompanists because they regard the music before them as straightforward musical expressions in the manner of a sonata or concerto. Accompaniments in the Lieder of insightful composers are a thing apart, however, exercises in chamber playing that require not only musical coordination but a nurtured emotional synchronization between singer and accompanist. This is not to say that the art of accompaniment (or, for that matter, of singing Lieder) requires anonymity or the suppression of personality: indeed, the finest Lieder accompanists – Graham Johnson, Gerald Moore, Geoffrey Parsons, and Erik Werba, for instance – are artists for whom the act of accompanying singers is both the most natural and the most sophisticated of musical conversation, in which an individual voice is always discernible. While the evidence of a single disc is not sufficient to add the name of Mr. Rastogi alongside those cited above, it is indicative of an apparent artistic sensitivity that shapes Grieg’s sometimes laconic Songs (nearly half of the Songs in this recital are of less than two minutes in duration) with bite that does not preclude grace. Longer, more lyrical lines are shaped with finesse, built upon a careful attention to the inflections of the text and nuances of the singer’s delivery. Mr. Rastogi distinguishes himself with complete command of the music Grieg sets before him and is a young pianist from whom much else (perhaps Grieg’s beautiful E-minor Piano Sonata and Violin Sonatas) will hopefully be heard on disc in future.

Mr. Weisser, a Norwegian baritone whose impressive diary of engagements seemingly belies his youth, is perhaps most known to the record-buying public for his singing of the title role in René Jacobs’ controversial recording of Mozart’s Don Giovanni on harmonia mundi, which followed a much-discussed production (recorded and released on DVD) at Baden-Baden’s Festspielhaus. A singer with a voice of natural beauty that requires little manipulation in order to depict complex emotions, Mr. Weisser brings to his performance of the Grieg Songs on this disc the additional benefit of being a native Scandinavian. It might be rather naïve to suggest that Mr. Weisser has these Songs ‘in his blood,’ so to speak, merely by being Norwegian, but his native understanding of the texts of the Songs is tremendously important. Small details of interpretation that would escape the notice of artists who have learnt the language by rote, solely for the purpose of singing the Songs, are surely apparent to a native speaker. The extent to which this is critical to a recital of art songs depends upon the quality of the voice singing them, and in this case the lovely, silver-hued quality of Mr. Weisser’s baritone ensures an enjoyable listening experience even if there were no great interpretive insights on offer. Fortunately, however, the disc is to be cherished as much for Mr. Weisser’s thoughtful interpretations – equally impressive in songs as different in character as ‘En Digters Sidste Sang’ (‘A Poet’s Farewell’) and ‘Trudom’ (‘Faithfulness’) – as for the attractiveness of his singing. Unlike many young singers, Mr. Weisser avoids the pitfall of singing this recital in a manner that causes the interpretations to seem studied: his singing, though subtle throughout, sounds spontaneous, suggesting not casualness but genuine affection for the music. Perhaps there is more than a kernel of truth to the many adages concerning the icy Nordic resolve for Grieg expresses darker feelings without wallowing in tonal quagmires (as his German counterparts were apt to do) or spinning endlessly aching melodies (comme les francaises), but Mr. Weisser’s performances of the Songs ensures that everything that Grieg means to say is said eloquently, resolutely but without excess. What Mr. Weisser achieves as a singer in this recording is a first-rate recital that reveals the unquestionable value of an overlooked repertory of fascinating songs. What he achieves as an exponent of music of his own fatherland is akin to what Victoria de los Angeles, Kathleen Ferrier, Dietrich Fischer-Dieskau, and Gérard Souzay accomplished in the songs of their respective native cultures.

It is flirting with folly to deem any performance definitive as this is to dismiss by default (if not always by intent) both all that has come before – and, in the context of Grieg’s Songs, neither the work of Kirsten Flagstad nor that of Anne Sofie von Otter can be dismissed – and what is possible in future. It is beyond doubt that a voice such as Flagstad’s is not likely to ever again be heard in Grieg’s Songs, but it is likewise doubtful that a recital as musically astute and emotionally fulfilling as this one by Johannes Weisser and Søren Rastogi is to be had (especially on disc) within the foreseeable future. It is also unlikely that, even with the espousal of artists of this caliber, the Lieder of Edvard Grieg will join their French and German brethren in the repertories of the world’s most discerning recitalists. The enchanting performances on this disc prove that the loss is as much theirs as it is Grieg’s and the individuals’ who love his music.

Pianist Søren Rastogi [Photo by Anders Hjerming]

[Note: Only hours after the posting of this article, the release of a complete edition of the Songs of Edvard Grieg was announced, combining seven previously-issued discs. The recordings, on the BIS label, feature Finnish mezzo-soprano Monica Groop, who is accompanied by pianists Love Derwinger, Ilmo Ranta, and Roger Vignoles. The compilation is scheduled for release in the UK on 1 June.]

28 April 2010

CD REVIEW: Georg Friedrich Händel – ORLANDO (C. Dumaux, E. de la Merced, R. Nicholls, J.M. Fumas, A. Buet; K617)

Händel's ORLANDO, HWV 31 (Dumaux, de la Merced, Nicholls, Fumas, Buet; Malgoire - K617 221/3) GEORG FRIEDRICH HÄNDEL (1685 – 1759): Orlando, HWV 31 – C. Dumaux (Orlando), E. de la Merced (Angelica), R. Nicholls (Dorinda), J.M. Fumas (Medoro), A. Buet (Zoroastro); La Grande Écurie et la Chambre du Roy; Jean-Claude Malgoire [recorded ‘live’ at the Théâtre Municipal de Tourcoing, France, on 4 May 2008; K617 221/3]

Ludovico Ariosto’s Orlando Furioso – first published in complete form in 1532 and at more than 38,000 lines among the longest poetic epics in European Literature – was to composers of the Eighteenth Century what the plays of Shakespeare were to their Nineteenth-Century successors: an irresistible source of heroic stories populated by legendary figures who nonetheless possessed endearingly ordinary qualities.  Inspiring operas from composers ranging from Rameau and Vivaldi to Piccinni and Haydn, Ariosto’s humanistic epic provided plots for three of Georg Friedrich Händel’s most compelling operas for London: Alcina, Ariodante, and Orlando.  The earliest of Händel’s three Orlando Furioso operas, Orlando was premiered at the King’s Theatre (now the home of the long-running West End production of Lloyd Webber’s Phantom of the Opera) on 27 January 1733.  The cast for the inaugural production, which ran for ten performances, included the world-famous Senesino as Orlando, Anna Maria Strada del Pò as Angelica, Celeste Gismondi as Dorinda, Francesca Bertolli as Medoro (a relatively rare instance in Händel’s London operas of an important male role being created by female contralto), and Antonio Montagnana as Zoroastro.  If not among the handful of Händel’s operas most known to Twenty-First-Century audiences, Orlando was one of the most notable successes of its composer’s London career, a score in which Händel’s skills as both musician and dramatist were tested and proved.

A depiction of Orlando in Ariosto's ORLANDO FURIOSO by French artist Gustave Doré

One of the most remarkable aspects of Ariosto’s literary epic – and, later, of Händel’s opera – is the uncommonly frank depiction of the hero’s [he is, incidentally, the famed Roland, one of Charlemagne’s most capable paladins] madness, which results from his unrequited love for the pagan princess Angelica (who, after a fashion that virtually demanded operatic treatment, is in love with Medoro, a Saracen knight).  The sensibilities of Renaissance writers were increasingly engaged by explorations of the intricacies of human psychology, and the madness of Orlando proved for Ariosto an opportunity for examining insanity within the context of an individual psyche rather than that of religious conventions as had been prevalent in earlier literary movements.  This psychological depth, combined with the fantastic staging possibilities offered by a plot containing battles and sorcery, attracted the artistic attentions of the most celebrated composers of the Baroque era.  The madness of Orlando was an unprecedented opportunity for composers to cast off musical formulae and compose ‘pure’ music to depict the wanderings of an afflicted mind.  In Vivaldi’s Orlando furioso, the title character’s madness is conveyed by lapses into French (which Vivaldi’s Venetian audiences are sure to have found hysterical in both senses of the term) and wordless variations on the Iberian folksong ‘La Folía,’ a veritable ‘hit’ tune that circulated throughout Europe during the Eighteenth Century in the form of variations by celebrated composers.  Händel brought even greater novelty to his depiction of Orlando’s madness, not by discarding traditional forms piecemeal but by turning them in on themselves in order to achieve the most intense dramatic expression with the most economical of means.  What Händel achieved in Orlando with the portrayal of psychological unraveling with relatively simple musical devices would remain unchallenged in its dramatic effectiveness until the development of the more extravagant mad scenes of Nineteenth-Century Italian bel canto.

Musically, Orlando deserves a place among the most distinguished operatic scores of Händel’s maturity.  Composing his music for a distinguished cast, Händel enriched each role in Orlando with arias and ensembles of beauty and brilliance.  Furthermore, there are no characters of secondary importance in Orlando, which allowed Händel to dedicate himself even more perceptibly than in his other operas for London to minute details of musical and dramatic characterization.  In this sense, Orlando is ultimately one of Händel’s most sensual and emotionally honest operas despite its exalted personages of lore.

The present recording, preserving a performance given on 4 May 2008 in the Théâtre Municipal de Tourcoing in a production by Gildas Bourdet, features the Baroque-specialist ensemble La Grande Écurie et la Chambre du Roy under the direction of their founder, Jean-Claude Malgoire.  A pioneering figure in the Early Music movement since his creation of La Grande Écurie et la Chambre du Roy in 1966, Maestro Malgoire has long inspired arguments among scholars and music lovers with the often idiosyncratic nature of his approach to Baroque operas.  His series of Händel opera recordings (Rinaldo, Serse, and Tamerlano) for CBS/Sony were subject to mixed receptions by critics despite their documentation of the work of several wonderful singers (especially Carolyn Watkinson, Ileana Cotrubas, Paul Esswood, and the young Barbara Hendricks), with much of the harshest criticism aimed at what was described as the astringent sound of the period string playing and bizarrely-inflected phrasing.  Maestro Malgoire’s forces have hardly proved to be alone in occasionally making unpleasant sounds, but in the course of the past three decades the ears of listeners have adjusted (and have heard far worse noises emerging from other period-instrument bands, to be frank).  This recording of Orlando is played with the verve characteristic of Maestro Malgoire’s work at its best, and the tones produced by his players fall pleasantly on the ears, on the whole.  Equally importantly, Maestro Malgoire’s conducting of the score reveals not only an acquaintance with the music but also a recognition of its significance in Händel’s operatic output.  Surely benefiting from having been recorded in performance, secco recitatives never drag or lose momentum, and Maestro Malgoire paces the performance with admirable attention to the cumulative impact of the music, bringing rhythmic vitality to the overtly dramatic scenes and welcome restraint to moments of lyricism.  For all that his work has not been universally appreciated, Maestro Malgoire remains a vital contributor to the Baroque Renaissance, and this performance of Orlando confirms that, in his fifth decade of music-making, his is a credible presence among the most accomplished conductors of Händel’s operas.

a scene from Gildas Bourdet's production of Händel's ORLANDO at the Théâtre Municipal de Tourcoing, 2008

Händel rarely lavished even upon his roles in other operas composed for the great Antonio Montagnana music of the quality that he created for Zoroastro.  Zoroastro in the context of Orlando is a ‘mago’ (magician), but it is clear from the profundity of the music that Händel wrote for the role that he may well have also had in his mind the Persian philosopher Zoroaster, albeit anachronistically (and, from a strictly philosophical perspective, erroneously) as the historical Zoroaster likely lived two millennia before Charlemagne’s reign in the Eighth Century.  A decade after the first performance of Orlando, the Persian Zoroaster would become the subject of an important tragédie lyrique by Jean-Philippe Rameau, and after another forty years the basis – arguably – for the character of Sarastro in Mozart’s Die Zauberflöte.  Allowing for the obvious differences in styles, the music for Händel’s Zoroastro would not be out of place in either Rameau’s opera or Mozart’s in terms of the dignity of utterance.  That dignity is well-served in the performance on this recording by Frenchman Alain Buet, who is variously billed as both a baritone and a bass.  Mr. Buet’s voice is stronger in the baritone range than in the lowest depths of the bass range, but he copes fearlessly with the considerable range demanded by Händel’s music.  Mr. Buet avoids the sluggishness of many larger-voiced singers in this repertory, delivering the rapid passagework with vigor and ease.  Mr. Buet’s Zoroastro is a presence both forceful and benevolent, and his performance ignores no aspect of the role.

Though created by a female singer, Medoro is sung in this performance by the French countertenor Jean-Michel Fumas, a fine singer whose work is too little-known in the United States, even among connoisseurs of Baroque music.  Mr. Fumas has collaborated often with Maestro Malgoire, and the conductor’s understanding of the singer’s needs in Medoro’s often daunting music is obvious.  Medoro is one of those Händel characters whose lot it is to more or less be in the wrong places at the wrong times, the unintentional hypotenuse of a love triangle resulting from the affections of both Angelica (who, though passionately desired by Orlando, remains true to Medoro) and Dorinda.  To audiences in the Twenty-First Century, this predicament introduces a subtle suggestion of comedy (a suggestion that becomes none too subtle in many productions of the opera), but Händel’s music reveals that the composer considered Medoro’s plight deadly serious.  Mr. Fumas, who also sings roles from the haute-contre repertory of his native country, possesses a voice of suitable richness to convincingly portray a male character, a trait surprisingly rare among countertenors.  As Medoro, Mr. Fumas brings admirable concentration to his performance, taking the care to maintain an even tone throughout his role’s most difficult passages.  As a result, the significance of Medoro in the overall drama of the opera is apparent.  Meeting the technical demands of Medoro’s music confidently, Mr. Fumas is free to focus on honing his interpretation of the role, ultimately contributing a performance that is wholly effective in its restraint and subtlety.

Singing the role of the shepherdess Dorinda, whose Arcadian existence is disrupted by the pangs of misbegotten love, the voice of British soprano Rachel Nicholls is one of bewitching purity.  The effect of hearing Ms. Nicholls in any of Dorinda’s pensive arias is like that of seeing the early-morning sunlight pouring through the windows of a great cathedral.  The sophistication inherent in Ms. Nicholls’ singing reveals that Dorinda is a character whose simplicity is that of honesty rather than banality.  Ms. Nicholls’ technique encompasses all of the tools needed to meet the challenges of Dorinda’s more spirited music, as well, and on the whole her performance is one of this recording’s greatest strengths and a superb achievement in recorded Händel singing.

The ‘international’ soprano (born in Australia but resident in Spain since an early age) Elena de la Merced is a recurrent presence among the casts of productions and recordings of Baroque operas.  She makes of Händel’s heroines something of a specialty, the blend of technical brilliance and natural timbral attractiveness in her voice proving ideal for the dueling fire-breathing and heart-breaking elements of Händel’s soprano roles.  Angelica is just such a role, split between extremes of exasperated vehemence and absolute dejection.  The darkness that invades Ms. de la Merced’s voice in moments of pathos does not shut out the light altogether, and as with Ms. Nicholls’ Dorinda there is to Ms. de la Merced’s Angelica a wonderfully refreshing quality of quietude.  Even in their bleakest musical moments, there is in the performances of both sopranos a prevalent sense of truth, of things being sorted out and set right before the final curtain.  As so often in opera, thoughtful artists prove that what seems on the page a manufactured lieto fine is in execution a deeply-considered resolution built gradually, if almost imperceptibly, by the composer.  That no single aria stands out for having received an especially fine performance from either Ms. Nicholls or Ms. de la Merced is indicative of the extremely high standards of singing achieved in this performance – a remarkable achievement indeed in the context of a single live, staged performance.

It is immediately apparent when hearing this recording that French countertenor Christophe Dumaux has an arrestingly beautiful voice, sweet-toned and true throughout his range.  It is more controlled than the voices of many countertenors and also possesses a greater spectrum of colors and dynamic contrasts.  His splendid technique notwithstanding, Mr. Dumaux’s singing in this performance is an exciting display of dramatic bravura, his vocalism always at the service of the text.  Occasionally, this dramatic vividness is at the expense of the beauty of Mr. Dumaux’s tone, but the commitment with which Mr. Dumaux completes every dramatic journey that he begins justifies his choices.  Not surprisingly, the apotheosis of Mr. Dumaux’s performance comes in Orlando’s celebrated mad scene, which Mr. Dumaux shapes delicately, the sorrow and disappointment that disrupt the character’s reason depicted with touching sincerity and musical sensitivity.  Throughout the performance, Mr. Dumaux combines the textual clarity typical of an accomplished verismo singer with his skills as an Händel singer of the first order, contributing an account of Orlando’s music that is cumulatively thrilling and moving.  Those who love Händel’s music owe a particular debt of gratitude to K617, the Convent of Saint Ulrich, and their ‘Chemins du Baroque’ initiative for adding to the Händel discography a recording of an important singer, unique in his Fach, in his prime singing one of the Saxon Master’s most compelling operatic characters.

Despite the presence in the catalogues of several fine recordings, Orlando has not been as fortunate as others among Händel’s operas in receiving the full attention of audiences and music-lovers.  One way in which the present recording might prove indispensible is that it offers evidence of the fact that Orlando is an opera with the capacity, drawn solely from Händel’s score, of proving as engaging, thought-provoking, and moving as Giulio Cesare, Rodelinda, or Tamerlano.  The title role is a tour de force for an insightful singer, and the multiple-venue production preserved on this recording was rightly centered on the standard-setting Orlando of Christophe Dumaux.  So much of Jean-Claude Malgoire’s work having been dismissed by critics with charges of inconsistency and idiosyncrasy, the consistent excellence of the performance and unerring validity of Maestro Malgoire’s pacing of the score are rewards of this recording that are perhaps more cherished for having been somewhat unexpected.  Above all, a quintet of very fine singers and a conductor who understands and supports their efforts prove anew that the barrier between Händel’s best operas and the international mainstream repertory is built of nothing more than unfamiliarity.